Hey Shane,

3 Parts basically in NY that I hunt:

1. Westchester County with the bow - it has some areas that look like NYC, but some, like Pound Ridge where I am in a deer management program with the local PD is loaded with deer. Took a 146 inch buck there last year. I also hunt Bedford and North Salem. If you get chance, hunt this area. It is so much like Ohio (which I go every year) it isn't funny. Now, if we could remove the tree-huggers and Hillary Clinton (who lives in Chappaqua) we would be in deer heaven.
2. Sullivan County - Wurtsboro/Ellenville NY. Not great nutrition for deer, but it is good for a nice 120+ deer if I put the time in.
3. Greene County - Catskill NY -if you kill a forkhorn, you are lucky, but, great for back straps in the fridge.