I have both in my quiver... The slicks group very good, but mine were grouping about 3 inches off from the field tips. Simple sight adjustment and they group dead center, but not exactly as the field tips. I like shooting bheads that group with the fieldtips and the rage do just that. You cant go wrong with either but the rage heads group the exact same spot as the fieldtips. The slicks were a tad off, but grouped just as well.