I haven' t shot either but currently own a Cougar Mag and Phantom Mag, both are very accurate, quiet, fast and functioned flawlessly in the woods and on the range. A buddy however just bought a Rage and loves it to death, he said it is the nicest bow he has ever shot. To be honest haven' t heard to many complain about any martin offering as of late, so I think you' ll be pleased with whichever you choose. If you can get your hands on a few and shoot a few arrows, let the feel due the talking!