man!! my buddy killed one JUST like that....

had what looked like a TINY moose antler on one side...it was just like a small mass of bone...nasty lookin thing....other was a perfect 4pt side....was an awesome buck....

i actually passed it...could see it had antlers just couldnt put legal points on it....had a great shot(rifle season before i bowhunted) he just kept his head well hidden...my buddy put legal points on his head and dropped him...he thought it was a half rack....boy were we all surprised...