Success in Rattle all depends on your area and the buck to doe ratio. In my area, I typically see more bucks than doe. I usually see numerous bucks with busted racks so I know they are fighting. Last year alone, I rattled in an 110" 8 point and then 2 other bucks 2 days later. These 2 fought 2 different times around me before I shot one of them.

One thing I have had success with is light rattling and more just clicking the tines together as opposed to the all out brawls you see on the tv shows.