It'd be nice to have one of each but I'd rather simply have one that can do both jobs. I figure the 3-d target can just as well be used as a decoy because deer don't have that good of vision anyway to pick out detail. Afterall, carboard cut-outs have been known to work so why wouldn't a 3-d target right?

Again, I want something that's relatively realistic looking, lightweight, detachable antlers,and at least the size of a 150 lb deer.

Any suggestions?