Rinehart 18-1 X3
I was looking for a good quality target that lasts regardless of costs. I shoot with Muzzy 4 blade practice blade broadheads about every other day between April thru December. Mine is over three years old and I still have not had a complete pass-through shot. Price has come down on these targets and I believe they are right about $100.00. For a target this durable, arrow removal is one hand easy (at least with the practice blades).
http://www.rinehart3-d.com/
I have never tried the other layered targets on the market or the Rinehart 3D targets, but the 18-1 did not dissapoint.