Lucan, WOW....if I were to choose which one of those two bucks to hunt, I would certainly go with the one in the back yard. The first buck looked to be a strong 2 1/2 yr so being he'll be 3 1/2 this year. The one behind your house looks like a fine 4 1/2 year old basedon body shape and antler characteristics.
The avatar is pretty comical if you ask me, it works for me,and if the rest of the team likes it then blessed be.