Here is what we have came up with so far...

Buck Brigaide
Team Droptine
Split Brow
Crabclaw
Buck Squad
Fair Chase Kings
Team Stud's Only
Whack 'Em n Stack 'Em
Team Muy Grande
Lung Busters
Pope and Young Squad
Bowhunter Brigade
Knights of the round table
Big Buck Down
The Archers
The Hounds of Bucksville
The Legends of Buck Creek (or hollow, valley, woods, anything nature)
The Killers
Bleeding Bucks
Shaft-em
Silent Death
Heart Stoppers
Trails to Trophies
Antler Addicts Anonymous
Whitetail Fanatics (this is the name of a magazine)
Broadheads and Blood Trails
Knights of the Treestand
Treestand Knights
Team DOA (Dead On Arrows)
Team BSA (Buck Shooters of America)
Team Thwaack
Legendary Whitetails
Junk Racks

While going through the names, I noticed that you have some from Virginia and Maryland... So I guess I was wrong about the whole midwest thing!!!