I think most of the revolvers you can pick are pretty darn good.
It's a feel thing and I happen to have choosen the Ruger for the smaller grip as it fits my hands well.
I also choose a 10" barrel as I bought it for hunting and this makes it more accurate.
I can comfortably hit a pie plate free hand @ 40 yards and with a rest I'll go around 75 yards.
I have a S&W .38 special and love that too, it's all how it feels to you???!
Another nice pistola I've used in the past is the Colt Anaconda, if your taking suggestions?