RE: I think the 45 LRH will do
Nice shooting! That is odd that both bullets shot to the same point of impact, but weird things happen sometimes, what can you say?
For deer hunting I'd definetly recommend the 200 grain XTP over the lighter Noslers. Noslers are excellent bullets, but 150 grains is a bit light for .40 cal IMO. I've used the 200 grain XTP to take several deer over the past couple years and it has performed excellent for me every time - all BOOM-flops. I was using a little bit hotter charges- 80 - 85 grains of 777.