Definately go with the Benelli. The Benelli will be better made. I have a mossberg pump and I know three other people who have mossberg pumps. And guess what everysingle one of them rattles. The forestock (i think thats what it is called) is generally really lose on mossbergs. I would definately go with the benelli, and if you have enough money i would get a better benelli in semi-auto for turkey.