I like the Goldtips myself and a 100grn broadhead. If i were going to hunt game bigger than deer i would shoot a heavier broadhead but for deer i think the 100grn is really all you need. According to the Goldtip charts at 54lbs i would go with the 3555 and a 100grn muzzy if you don' t plan on turning your poundage up any but if you do the 5575 would be better imo. If you switch to carbon and a lighter broadhead your gonna get more fps which in turn will shoot flatter and maybe give you a little more distance how much i don' t know but the flop side is increased noise and less ke with the lighter arrow. Good Luck!