Not the same deer. The buck from last year doesn't have the brow tine length. I know he could have grown bigger but the first deer doesn't have that characteristic. Also the first deer has G3s that are longer than the G2s. That would remain constant. Also, the first deer is a main frame 9 and the ones from this year is an 8. I know he could have lost a point but that usually doesn't happen till they start going down hill. He will also go over 140 too.