C'mere deer has never worked for anyone that I know who has used it. Hank Parker made it seem like it was almost "Cheating" to use that in his commercials it was so good. I never saw any difference. Buck Grub seems to work pretty good, for some reason the yearling deer don't like it. Ive seen them smell that and jump away from it and go to the corn or sugar beets. All mature deer seem to like it a lot. It seems weird to me that would happen, but oh well, Im not looking for the yearlings anyway!