I'll take woods everytime. As a bowhunter I really don't enjoy sitting on a field watching deer feed 200 yards away. In the woods you'll have deer activity longer and earlier, more rutting activity, acorns, blah blah blah. As a bowhunter I see no way to hunt a field edge only. Your deer is heading for the woods as soon as he's shot so you're trespassing to recover. Fields are tough to hunt in the mornings as the deer are usually in them or bedded on the edge of the field until first light. Tough to get in undetected in most situations. Of course hunting the fields and the woods is the ideal. You're not stepping on toes and can get around. Are these actual senerios or are you hypothetically thinking again?