Well, I am familiar with deer in your/our area , and I would say 3 year old is good. Spread I'm going to put at 18 or a little over, and gross might make 130, but when it is all said and done I don't think he will make P&Y, even though it would be touch and go... Another year, and no problem, he is a little light on mass also. But I would still shoot him, he's pretty nice.