Personally, I'm partial to my Ithica. Been shooting it since 1968. I bought a Winchester 1300 turkey gun a couple of years ago and tried to use it last year. I killed a turkey with it, alright, but I just never liked shooting that gun. The reason is that the Win and the Ithica are set up backwards on the safety. My Ithica's safety is behind the trigger guard and the Win's is in front. If you have a preferance, or have been shooting a particular gun for a while and like it, these seemingly small things can make or break your ease of use of that weapon. The ones you named are all good quality weapons, just pick the one that fits you.