WOW, between a rock and a hard place. Sounds like he is the man and knows his stuff but then again all day hunts during the rut are very common practice. IMO bucks lose some of that edge during this time of year that could get them killed from making mistakes, and those magic between hours are great chances of scoring. Sounds like hunting all day might make tension so you will probbly be better off doing it his way. he has been very successful so keep that in mind. and the best of luck to you when you go. score a bigun