I'm one of the guys that don't think there are to many deer,and where I live there aren't.The more does equal more bucks.
I just feel that there are allot of feel good herd managers out there,and if they really cared about herd dynamics like they say they do then there is no justifiable explanation for the killing of any bucks.
I listen to the whining about some one killing a button buck,but your a hero for killing a 3.5 year old. A buck is a buck young orold. The herd ratio is what we're talking about here.