For basketball it's hard to go against Bird, but after Jordan's buzzer beater in the finals I'll take him.

For hunting I don't know. I have known some incredible target/3d shooters that have come apart with a big buck in front of them. Trad guys seem to have ice in their veins, but I'd hate to lose my house if that deer is 30 yards away. I might have to go with Troy or Hunsucker. Both guys seem to be able to get it done with the big boys in front of them and it's usually a short tracking job.