My 3 biggest range from 200 - 225. My oldest, 7 1/2, weighted only 167.Deer are like people. They come in different body shapes and lengths. Without weighing them it's easy to be off in weight. My dad shot a long bodied8 pointer that looked huge. He weighed 140# he was real run down from the rut.
I totally agree with you guys about guys guessing at their deer's weight. They are just like fishermen - stretching the weight a bit!