I went through a similar dilemma last year trying to choose an autoloader, at the start i wanted a cheaper model for a fun trap league but asI dug deeper into the process and started handling them I ended up with a Beretta 391 (3" no need for 3.5" as i have a benelli nova pump with 3.5" chamber and never use it for waterfowling). I have flung shot from light trap loads to 3" faststeel and no problems. First shotgun I actually can say "I love" - feels and swings great.