Thanks everybody.
I decided to throw a tape on the skull that I found, it measured right at 104"! 16.5" inside spread, 19" main beams, 7" G-2's. I would have loved to see what it would have been at 3.5 y.o. but I will never know.
What really suprised me was how good of condition the skull and rack were in. This area is littered with rabbits and squirrels, but there was only a very small amount of chewing on the end of the main beam.
I am going to bleach the skull and I am going to try to find a light brown stain to put on the antlers and hopefully get the skull looking good. I am gonna get some rough cut cherry and make a table top euro mount out of it and incorporate a picture of him from my game camera. I am about 99% sure its the same buck, what do you guys think?