I'm skeptical (as far as it being the same buck in most instances). I watched 4 bucks work the same scrape one day......thinking I was sitting over a big boy scrape. The first was a little half-rack 4 pointer......the last was a BB.

I see scrape lines where I hunt that encompass 10 or more trees in a 100yd stretch. I wonder why the same buck would do this......but I don't "know". I didn't see any of them made.

I also don't hunt this type of sign. Personal preference.