It really does not matter if P&Y or B&C will take these animals or not. I was the Illinois deer classic this year, a guy I know brought in a road kill buck. It was scored and put into the books. He told them that it was an archery kill and I guess he must have used once of his archery tags on it, I don't really know. The fact is, people can go on HF hunts and have their animals put into the books if they so desire, there are ways around it for sure. As long as there are people that are willing to pay crazy amounts of money for some big bone, these places will continue to operate. I must say, I did feel a little sick looking at the pics of the bucks in post, knowing how they were kept and knowing they were killed for their head gear alone, I don't understand it, but I am not going to cast judgement on those who decide this is the way for them to get their trophy.