Why don't you shoot a Benelli like your sig says? Pretty hard to beat 'em.
Of what you listed I'd take the Beretta... sell it for an old 870 and go to canada in october with the change.
No seriously, I'd give it to the Beretta or the Winchester. There are plenty of 1187s in the field running well, but I see more issues with 1187s at the gun shop than almost any other semi auto, and certainly more than I should see with a gun at its price point.