I didn't read 100% of the post just the first few pagesand the last couple to keep up with where this is going, and maybe this has been said.

I not for state legislative restriction on antler size. Most do nothing but remove the good genetics in the herd. I've seen plenty of ten point year and half olds. And this year I shot at a six point four and half old. As far as earn a buck programs the jury is still out for me, but I still don't like the gov. getting involved. One thought is do you turn someone into a poacher when the first deer they see is a booner.

Now with that said I try to practice QDM and take an average of 8 does a year (primarly bow hunting). It should be your personal goals. But if you do want to have a balance herd (like they are born into) you will take out some does because most guyes are taking bucks and no does. They are just hurting themselves. A balanced herd will allow for maximum nutrition, better rut activity, and larger deer. True QDM is about a balance herd. Thier goals of QDMare to have 1:1 buck doe ratio. The side effects are the rest.

It's still about your choise and any animal you take had better put a smile on your face or why did you take it. I've took younger bucks in the past and who's tosay my finger will not itch in the future. I just hope it doesn't. If you are my neighbor I will try to get you on board with me, but I won't force the issue I'll try to lead by example.

I hope this helps you understand QDM a little better. Most have it misconsturd with Trohpy Management, and if you still have questions please PM me and I try to get you the answers.