RE: Am I "selling out"?
You should hunt for your own reasons. If you think you are selling out that is all that really matters. Whatanyone may think will be based on their experiences and their hunting grounds, not yours. I don't think the "herd" cares one way or another.
For what it's worth, if you spend your time on the new 200 acres and are enjoying yourself and your hunting I would think that is the furthest thing away from selling out.