RE: Would you take this shot?
HMMM for those of you who said there are no legal issues. Would this not (as they stand) be the definition of taking refuge in water?
A condition in which it's illegal to shoot deer in both Ohio and PA that I know of. How about your State?
Also even if that wasn't a concern, would you not be just as worried that the one you shot would drag the other down and drown it?
I don't think I could do it. I really don't!