ORIGINAL: HOGHUNTINGUNLIMITED
ORIGINAL: BGfisher
This really isn't a fair question because the two bows are not the same price. At least the MSRP price.
Ok what if they were the same price as right now in any archery shop!!!?
But they are not. How about compare a Mathews with an MSRP of $599 against the FireCat which is MSRP of $599. That way we can eliminate the "What if" portion of your question. Compare apples to apples.