HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - For or Against Mandatory Bowhunter Education
Old 02-28-2008 | 02:55 PM
  #198  
Badger_Girl93
Fork Horn
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 298
Likes: 0
Default RE: For or Against Mandatory Bowhunter Education

ORIGINAL: iamyourhuckleberry

So then Badger, what would you have us do? Do you concede that a problem exists?If so, how do we fix it?
In my state there is one HE course that is required to get any hunting license. I am happy with that system....I don't see a problem with it.

I never said that educating bowhunters had something todo with educating college students. I wasmerely pointing out thatthe suggestion thateducation is good, therefore we should make itmandatory, is not very solid.

For example: military service is good...should we make it mandatory? college is good...should we make it mandatory? having a job is good...should we make it mandatory? reading to your kids is good...should we make it mandatory? Donating time to help at a homeless shelter is good...should we make it mandatory? Being a good mentor and taking kids hunting/fishing is good...should we make it mandatory?

There are lots of good things that are not mandatory. Suggesting thatsince something is simply good, we should make it mandatory in order to impose the goodness on everyone is a pretty lame argument (see my examples above). That's all I was saying there. A simple analogy.

What would YOU have us do?
Badger_Girl93 is offline  
Reply