That is fare to add another ethical question, but understand my circumstance is different than 10 guys heading out and 1 shooting 5 deer. In my situation, the deer was going to rot and I put it on the table for someone who did not get a deer.For your question, well IMO that is wrong. This actually happened to me and it was legal. I was hunting a DMU and heard a shot every 30 minutes for the first 2 hours on opening day. I got down from my stand and walked in that direction. I stumbled out to an opening where the guy was in a tree and said, hey those are my deer. I looked and he had 2 small bucks and 3 doe dead and still hunting.