Never hunted the rosevelts. Will someday just to try them out. Have plenty of elk in Montana and theneighboring states to hunt each fall. When elk hunting gets in your blood its hard to get out the blood. I love to hunt anything that walksbut elk are pretty close to the top..Even a vetern elk huntercan learn something new. The challenge they pose eachseasonmakes the thrill even sweeter and keep coming back for more, esp. walking up on a downed bruiser.What part of the state of Idaho did you hunt?Pretty sure Im heading to the Frank Church this fall unless something comes up, already have the tag in hand.