I think Buckmasters is a solid magazine, to which my family subscripes to. It has pretty decent photography and a lot of member success stories which are cool to read. When it comes to in-depth knowledge of the the Whitetail and its ways, I would say that those articles are a little vague. They have some how-to articles concerning how to hunt the rut, tree stand placement, etc. but again those just cover the basics. Overall, on a scale of 1-10 I would give Buckmasters a 6.5.
I recommend Deer and Deer Hunting.