Obviously you havn't been around here long enough to understand the statement. There have been many discussions on here over the years about fenced hunting areas with the opinion of many that "I wouldn't hunt in a fenced area no matter how big it is". With the fact that the deer are on an island a long way from mainland they are basically in a big pen with the water as their fence. Maybe you understand now.

According to your reasoning, north america is an island also. I would love to hunt Anticosti. I think it would be alot more fair than Texas.