I have an SKB bow case and a Winchester gun case(thanks to the in-laws for the latter). The SKB getsw packed in the back of the pickup for the annual bowhunt trip ti Michigan. (1000 miles from here). I know for sure that the SKB will hold up to some abuse(thanks to buddies trying to break it for me, their jealous). The Winnie is made from aluminum around the edges and some type of ribbed rubber covering the rest. It seems very durable except for the locks, like someone said earlier. Anyway, they are both good for me. Hope this helps.