I agree. Tough call. For me it would initially be an issue of length versus weight. The Allegiance is a couple inches longer but the mass weight of the General is a pound more. You can interpret that information one of two ways. In terms of the weight of the General, a heavier bow is more stable and thus inherently more accurate. In one sense this is a good thing for the General since the axle to axle length is fairly short at 31 inches. Also consider that the Center Pivot riser design tends to distribute the weight over more of the full length of the bow making it, again, more stable.

On the other hand the added weight can be a bit tiresome initially especiallyif you are not accustomed to it. In that sense the Allegiance would be a better option since its weight is more in the average range.

Also consider that thereis alot of emphasis put on longer axle to axle length bows and increased downfield accuracy...and for good reason. With that thought in mind though, and as suggested above, one of the other Bowtech offerings might suit your particular combination of needs better. In this sense I am thinking of the 101st Airborne. Its axle to axle length is a bit longer at 36 inches plus you have the option of switching between smooth and fast modules to customize the draw cycle a bit. You could easily use the smooth mods for hunting and/or field archery while relying more on the speed mods for 3D.

Just some things to think about. Hope it proves helpful.