I wouldn't take the shot, because I just don't think Im good enough to make, plain and simple. The same way I won't shoot past 25 yds even if he is broadside, just me, Im not that great of a shot. I do fine 25 and in, Im deadly. Get em out past that and I won't try em. Never have shot a deer past 25 yds, I just don't feel comfortable. Heck I passed up a deer that probably went 135-140 2 years ago, droptine buck, he was 21" wide. He was broadside at 40 yds licking the face of a six pnt and never knew I was there. I just couldn't bring myself to trying him. At least I will admit to it though!!