i like narrow with tall tines. i think thats because we seem to shot/see alot of them.for about 6 season i have flip/flopped back and forth. buck with a bow, doe with a gun. doe with a bow, buck with a gun the next year. until this year, a doe each.anyway, the last 2 bucks with a bow have been tall and narrow. but i will settle for a 160 inch no matter what characteristics it has.LOL.