Having gotten both the Guardian and the General, having only one to choose from, I'd pick the General. The smooth, shockfree and whisper quiet not that the Guardian isn't because last year when I shot the Guardian (Matt/PA's) I found it to be the quietest, smoothest bow I ever shot, until the General. Yes, you give up a little speek but the General is still all the speed you need. The difference is mute. The Guardian may give a little more forgiveness but the more than adequate brace on the General proves to be very, very accurate. It's a very tough choice and one reason I chose the General is the short ATA (shortest ATA I've ever liked) and overall shootability. Good luck in your decision and be sure to post pics.