ORIGINAL: brucelanthier
Don't disagree and they say that under certain circumstances that the ratio can get out of whack but those circumstances are rather extreme. Not to say that the extreme circumstances didn't exist where you hunted in parts of Wis. But, barring those extreme circumstances the ratios can't really get out of whack.
Those instances are not rare, they are extreme and do get that out of whack. I can only say this for Wis. I've hunted several areas where the ratio isfrom 1 buck/8-10 does to 1 buck /15+ does.
Then I hop across the border to Ill and hunt spots as good as 1/3.