RE: Who would shoot?
Driving 1 mph over the speed limit is against the law. Throwing a cigarette butt out your window is against the law. Drinking and driving is against the law. Inflating your deductions while filing taxes is against the law. Accessing your neighbor's cable TV is against the law. Downloading music on the internet is against the law. Copying DVDs from blockbuster is against the law. Owning an un-registered firearm is against the law. Smoking pot is against the law. Taking a perscription that was written for someone else is against the law. Keeping a fish that is 1/8" too short is against the law. Driving with an expired inspection or registration is against the law.
How many of you choose to break one of those laws? To those who do, why is shooting a buck any worse than breaking one of those laws?
I'd shoot that deer 10 out of 10 times.