Wow, I didn't realize I would begin such a tremendous reaction with this topic.I simply say this; The skill to hunting is getting the deer close enough for a shot and as long as that shot comes from a weapon that is legal, then the weapon of choice should not be an issue. I use my crossbow, downed three deer with it in five years without a miss, and I will continue to use it without shame. It is legal and that is all that should matter.
Bozman