They will both do very well or very bad depending on what land they are on. The skilled guy will just do a little better in each place.
_____________________________
Atlasman, I' m about to quit,but aren' t you saying skill is more important than land in the success of the harvest ,cause it sure looks like your skilled hunter is doing better both places (?)
Todd1700 , I know how hard Alabama public land is ,that' s where I do most of my hunting when I can ,probably about an hour and a half from you. BTW I meant to tell you nice deer !