It is an ok idea, just that it is gone about all wrong. It is supposed to be antlerless only, but the bucks are shedding their antlers already, so alot of big bucks could still get shot accidentaly, not counting the antlered bucks that are shot on "accident" I hope it never happens again, I had no problem filling my shotgun tag. I waited to see what the weather would be like, and waited for second,then didn't buy my tag till the night before 2nd season anyway.