Recurves are generally cut closer to centershot, and that makes them less critical on arrow spine. So, it's easier to find arrows that will shoot well from them. Most recurves have a long sight window similar to a compound, so it will give new switchover shooters a better feeling of familiarity.

On the other hand, longbow grips are almost exactly the same as on modern compounds, so recurves don't have it all on the familiarity scale.

Other than those few things, smoothness of draw, arrow speed, forgiveness have to be judged when comparing individual bows nowadays. I've always rated recurves a little easier to shoot well than longbows, but that's probably because I shoot recurves better than I do longbows. Guys like Chad, who shoot better with longbows than with recurves, will rate the longbow over the recurve.

It'sactually a matter of personal preference. No way to really tell which type bow will work best for you until you've shot at least several of each. But I still think a recurve is the best starter bow for a traditional newbie.

Get one long enoughthat it is at least twice your draw lengthand with a draw weight light enough for you to hold full draw for at least 10 seconds before you start shaking.

I've never liked the idea of telling someone to start with a really lightweight bow. People are put together differently and one person might really need a very light weight, someone else might be a real gorrilla and be able to use something much heavier. A bow you can handle is essential to learning good shooting form. Just be honest with yourself where that limit lies. We're setting you up to be a good traditional shot, not looking to win any he-man contests. [8D]