I passed on a 150 class 10 point last week for the sole reason that he had most of his G2 broken off. I have killed other deer with broken tines that I didn't see before shooting, and my philosophy is that how they hit the ground is how they are mounted.

I have Camtrakker pictures of another buck during muzzleloader season and more during rifle season, and by rifle season, he had broken off most of one browtine. He is a mid 160's class buck, and since I have pictures of him "intact", I might consider having him repaired if I had killed him.