Well, I can't speak for Springfield, but I have a Kimber Warrior and couldn't be happier. It eats everything that I throw at it whether it be ball ammo, hollow point ammo or popcorn handloads. I have heard that Kimber had some problems with some parts breaking a few years ago, and I've also heard that this issue has been fixed. I'm sure that either of the pistols that you've mentioned will be a very good pistol for you and will give you many years of use if taken care of. Good luck with yourdecision. Simp