I think the question changed!! If your talking guided or unguided, I take unguided every time!!

I've felt a different sense of accomplishment forevery animal I've harvested, no two are the same!Some you work hard for, some you don't! I'm still damn proud and thankful for each and every one!

Buck of a lifetime?
I'd rather hunt my own land forever and not get one, than have someone say sit here, it will be by at 5.

edit
Not that I would never go on a guided hunt, I just don't think I would ever consided a buck taken on a guided hunt,a buck of a lifetime!